According to the film, Dr. Cline fathered at least 94 children via artificial insemination that the other half-siblings know about. I cannot even begin to imagine how violated she must have felt to find out.#OurFather pic.twitter.com/wR30amM6ey. He was the fertility specialist in Indianapolis at the time. Matt figured it out before his mom did. But White replayed the sequence of events in her mind. (It was introduced in the general assembly, and seemed to be gaining momentum.) All of those are mood enhancers that bring about wonderful feelings for them. She continued: We came in for a medical procedure., More than three decades later, she now says, I feel like I was raped 15 times., In those same three decades, the mores around sex, assisted reproduction, and medical authority have changed, too. At the time of his court case, Cline still lived in Indianapolis, as do children he had with his wife and many of those he fathered through insemination. Who is Dr. Donald Cline and How Many Children did Cline father? One of Cline's children, Heather Woock, spoke to The Atlantic in 2019, two years after she learned of her strange lineage through a barrage of Facebook messages from family members she never. Jacoba Ballard, from Indiana, discovered Dr Donald Cline was her father in 2014 Cline, a fertility specialist, secretly fathered dozens of children in '70s and '80s The doctor used his own sperm . For years, Ballard and her half-siblings have wondered what led Cline to lie to his patients and use his own sperm to impregnate them. May 22, 2022 4:38 p.m. PT. He understood why she felt violated. She named him Matthew, gift from God, because she thought of the sperm donation as a gift then. The day before, he and his mother and several of his half siblings had had a meeting with the president pro tempore of the Indiana Senate, Rodric Bray. Donald Cline has two legitimate children - those he raised with his wife Susie. Her mother, Deborah Pierce, was artificially inseminated by Dr. Donald Cline, and Ballard thought there might be one or two other people conceived from the same donor, according to The Atlantic and ABC30 News.She found her first sibling on an online forum for donor-conceived children, where she connected . He still thinks about the case often. Tim DeLaney, the prosecutor in this case, told me he saw the original wrong as a transgression by a person in power. The documentary follows Dr. Donald Cline, a fertility clinician who fathered upwards of 50 children (likely closer to 90) without his patients' consent or knowledge. Is it sad that month to say, Unfortunately, Mrs. Jones, [the donor] couldnt come because of an emergency. Cline fathered at least 94 biological children, according to the documentary, but the exact number of children conceived is impossible to know. But artificial insemination still requires an exchange of bodily fluids that can be procured only through sexual stimulation. He interned at Methodist Hospital after receiving his undergraduate degree and then his M.D. In the fall, they started sending letters to Indiana legislators urging them to support the fertility-fraud bill. The four of them took 23andMe tests to confirm they were half-sisters, but the results revealed they also had four more half-siblings. Donald Lee Cline (born December 10, 1938) is a convicted felon and an American former medical doctor of obstetrics and gynaecology. Will John Bolton Bring on ArmageddonOr Stave It Off? At first there were just . Was it a religious thing? Clines jail sentence of 365 days was suspended. But the message contained one detail that spooked her. Lastly, this user was sickened by the knowledge that another 45 known infertility specialists have committed the same crime as Cline: Just watched 'Our Father' on Netflix and I am so sickened that this is an actual problem. It's been estimated that he illegally fathered anywhere from 50 to 90 children, but that number keeps going up all the time, especially now with the release of the documentary. But his disbalance mind made him a victim of fraud which he did with his many patients. Cline opened his clinic in 1979, when infertility practice was still a newand relatively unregulatedmedical specialty. The website says that they provide encouragement and practical help to those who are striving to raise a large and growing, godly family in todays world! Quiverfull also writes that they welcome those with families of any size. In 2014, Indianapolis resident Jacoba Ballard wondered if she had any unknown siblings. Some of his donor children told me their mothers did not think of Clines actions as sexual when they found out the truth. InSarah Zhang's 2019 article for The Atlantic, 'The Fertility Doctor's Secret,' she explained how she quickly connected with another woman whose mother had also been treated by Cline. 'It's disgusting'. Jacoba who felt she didn't belong in her family took a DNA test at the age of 33 in 2014. It was in the court that many of Cline's biological children saw him for the first time, as the man pleaded guilty to having . Its this identity crisismore than Clines inexplicable actionsthat shes still working through. White went to Purdue at the same time as one of his half brothers. Cline is currently living in Indianapolis, Indiana as a free man, confirmed by The Atlantic, and lives fairly close to some of the children he fathered. Here was her biological father, but he radiated no paternal warmth. Our Father unfurls the case of Donald Cline, a former fertility doctor who fathered almost 100 of his patients' children without their consent. Did you really think that we wouldnt meet? 45 KNOWN infertility specialists have used their own sperm to impregnate women without consent or knowledge. Matt brought chicken wings, and he sweated over the grill cooking them. Her heritage turned out to be exactly what she had thoughtScottish, with English, Irish, and Scandinavian mixed inand she never bothered to click on the link that would show whether anyone on the site shared her DNA. One sibling sold another a wagon at a garage sale. Dr. Donald Cline, 77, admitted to six now-adult children that he'd used his sperm while treating their moms; he's facing two felony counts . pic.twitter.com/wsroSr1osG, Angela Ganote (@angelaganote) May 9, 2022. His mother, Liz White, had been trying to conceive with her husband for two and a half years when their fertility doctor referred them to Cline, who used fresh donor sperm instead of frozen, which had a higher success rate at the time. Around the time The Atlantic article was published, the number of children Cline fathered with his patients was known to be more than 50. Our Father How Many Siblings were revealed, and investigations took place. For months, nothing much happened. When she began connecting with her siblings, she realized their mothers had also been treated by Cline. I know Im going to call them and Im going to ruin their life, Ballard said on the documentary. It was only 35 years laterwhen Cline was in the newsthat she and her best friend realized they had both gone to him. Cline was a highly-respected fertility doctor a the time. Not one to give up, Pancoast tried something new. A 1977 survey found that more than half of the doctors did not even keep records, so as to leave no paper trail connecting donor and child. As of the Our Father production, there are currently 94 Cline siblings however, it's thought that there could be more. It teases the story of Dr. Donald Cline, a former fertility doctor who used his own sperm in donations, which resulted in his fathering at least 50 children throughout the 1970s and '80s. The answer, Ballard and her half siblings assumed, was in their DNA. In retrospect, finding her first half siblings was too easy. If he truly believed he was doing nothing wrong, why did he deceive his patients? Colver was more measured. But as Ballard says, she believes there are more of Cline's kids out there. 'You're praying, "Please don't let it be somebody I know. The rollercoaster rise of Elon Musk: Billionaire Tesla From blushing bride to bikini model! The survey did not ask, however, whether the patients in those cases were aware that their doctor was also their sperm donor. Everyone pitched in a little. Cline, he said, lives down the street over there. His office was decorated with photos of babies hed helped conceivea mundane detail that seems unsettling in retrospect. Joseph has been very involved with the Facebook group, while his twin wants nothing to do with it. After months of research and conversations with her many 23andMe matches, Ballard began to piece together the disturbing truth: Donald Cline, a man known as one of the most renowned fertility experts in Indiana, had inseminated dozens of women with his own sperm without their consent or knowledge. Ballard took a 23andMe test in 2014, and learned she had seven half-siblings. It was almost like this perfect Aryan clan,' Ballard said in the documentary. The resemblance between Matt and a young Cline is uncanny. (Woocks parents eventually told her theyd gone to Cline for donor insemination, but theyd had no idea he was the donor.) Their names are in the documentary because they appeared on the 23andMe website as being related to one of the other children fathered by Cline. According to her DNA, Woock, too, was one of his children. While searching for answers, four of the eight siblingsfiled complaints withIndianas attorney general and asked for their suspicions that Cline had used his own sperm in patients to be investigated. Ignorance is bliss, she told me, wistfully drawing out the last word. Matt rented out a picnic pavilion, and brought name tags because many of the siblings were meeting for the first time. In 2017, he was convicted on two counts for obstructing the police's investigation. Is Dr Donald Cline still married? Madeira took an interest in the case and helped write the fertility-fraud bill. She found Clines childrenthose he raised with his wifeand his adult grandchildren on Facebook and sent them a group message. She made Tyler swear never to tell his dad. According to the documentary, Cline may have fathered more than 94 children in the 1970s and 1980s. It wasn't until 2015, when some of the secret children began taking at-home DNA tests, that Cline's covert insemination of the women over his 40-year career was uncovered. I was like, Oh my goodness, I think that is my sister, Ballard says. Netflix's latest documentary Our Father has got us all talking. For Matt White, watching all this play out awoke a sense of purpose. Have something to tell us about this article? Jackie Collins taught me everything I know. Four of the eight siblings decided to file complaints with Indianas attorney general, saying they suspected that Cline had used his own sperm in patients and asking for an investigation. The doctor's actions were revealed by one of his children, Jacoba Ballard. Ballard and her half-siblings were determined to seek justice, but his actions weren't technically considered a crime. Lisa Shepherd, "Sibling #33", who is raised and spoke about the anxieties she faces daily. Cline himself, whose religious convictions and affiliations, victims believe, border on eugenics, was not interviewed for the documentaryan absence that brings those familiar with the narrative no closer to understanding its central motives. Losing the genetic connection with her father meant losing the story she had literally written about who she was and how she came to be. Despite Susie, Donald Cline's wife, not being a major part of the Netflix documentary, it is revealed that she also received treatment from her husband at the fertility clinic. Maybe hes that delusional., When Donald Cline opened his clinic in 1979, infertility was a relatively new medical specialty. A fertility doctor used his sperm to impregnate so many women without their consent & also passed on health issues. They have different personalities, too. Check out more of our Entertainment and Documentaries coverage or visit our TV Guide to see what's on tonight. Powered by. That would have meant coordinating the schedule of the sperm donor with the appointment of the ovulating patient several days a month, every month. I met White, now 36, at a bakery in Indianapolis last November, the morning after the first storm of the season had shellacked the roads in ice. Happy is the man that hath his quiver full of them: they shall not be ashamed, but they shall speak with the enemies in the gate. In 2022, the number is 94, according to the documentary. They saw a doctor who cared more about his professional success than his patients well-being. Investigators showed up at Clines house with a search warrant for his DNA. But no: They both had Clines DNA. But, oddly, she didnt seem angry at Cline so much as angry at being found out. So why was being grilled about her books on Mastermind so Why should I be asked to tip when I shop online? He told his patients the donors were medical residents, claiming he only used each donor's sperm for three successful pregnancies, Jason Hyatt (pictured) recalled his shock when he discovered how many relatives he had due to Cline's horrific deception, 'When I opened up Ancestry, I had over 3,000 hits,' he explained, 'When I opened up Ancestry, I had over 3,000 hits,' Jason Hyatt recalled in the trailer, while someone else added: 'I dread every new match that comes, but they just keep coming.'. She is 30 in the photo. According to Netflix, Cline inseminated at least 50 people with his own sperm without their consent, and he has at least 50 children, proven by DNA tests. When Amy was conceived, her parents had promised never to tella promise her mom had kept even though Amys father died years ago. Ballard remembers this first family reunion of sorts as oddly matter-of-fact. It was Cline's son who helped organize a meeting between the doctor and six of the newly-discoveredhalf-siblings, including Ballard. In some instances, state prosecutors said, Dr Cline even told women that he was using their husbands' sperm but provided his own. Dr. Donald Cline is an American fertility specialist from Indiana University School of Medicine who abused the trust of his patients by impregnating dozens of women with his own sperm without their knowledge or consent known as fertility fraud. For more from the biggest stars in TV, listen to the Radio Times podcast with Jane Garvey. He read them Bible verses from a notepad. Ballard struggled with what it meant, existentially, to have inherited the DNA of a man who would lie to his patients and abuse his position as a doctor. In addition to Cline, the documentary claims, there are 44 other doctors who have used their own sperm to impregnate their patients; they, too, were discovered through at-home DNA testing. I have no clue., Maybe he really thought he was helping people. Until very recently in human history, reproduction always required an act of sexual intimacy. Cline has admitted to using his own sperm about 50 times, which is about the number of children who have been identified through DNA. The women were none the wiser for years, believing they were using. They are just a few of the many people forging connections after the initial shock of a DNA surprise. Dr. Don Cline Now: Is the Our Father Doctor in Prison Today. By the 1970s, hundreds of doctors were performing donor insemination across the U.S., but secrecy still prevailed. We exist to serve those believers who trust the Lord for family size, and to answer the questions of those seeking truth in this critical area of marriage, the website says. from Indiana University. . Finally, a woman who shared some of their DNA told them she had a cousin named Donald Cline who was a doctor in Indianapolis. They said that decades ago, without ever telling his patients, Cline had used his own sperm to impregnate women who came to him for artificial insemination. Theres really no comparison between the two.. Dr. Donald Cline has been famous in the media as the fertility doctor who inseminated his sperm into several women without consent. Tyler now wonders whether she knew all along that the sperm came from a donor, even if she didnt know that donor was Cline. That gave him a sense of what his mother had gone through to have him. Together they had a daughter named Donna, who worked as a nurse at her dad's practice, and a son called Doug.. So sorry, were going to have to wait until next month? Of course it is. You and I gotta take it to the grave, she said. Netflix. Please don't let it be somebody I dated,"' one woman shared. D uring the 1970s and '80s, a fertility specialist in Indiana named Dr. Donald Cline inseminated dozens of patients with his own sperm, without their knowledge or . 'Growing up, I felt different,' she explained in the film's shocking new trailer. He outweighs me by 30 pounds, he says. Cline was a top fertility doctor in Indianapolis; he had a lot of patients. He wasnt charged with battery with bodily wasteIndiana considers that a crime only if its done in a rude, insolent, or angry manner. He wasnt charged with criminal deceptionany records were long gone. That we wouldnt maybe date? He wanted to have control over, I dont know, Indiana?, Honestly, I dont know. True to their different personalities, they reacted in opposite ways. The half siblings turned the question over in their minds. They climbed trees and got sticky with sap. And in 2018, the Medical Licensing Board of Indiana terminated Donald's medical license after he was convicted on two felony counts. She began reaching out to each one. Jacoba, 41, was secretly fathered by fertility expert Dr Donald Cline - who used his own sperm to impregnate patients without their knowledge. The true nature of Cline's medical practice may have remained a secret if. Adoptees have reunited with their birth families. An actor portrays Cline in Netflix's new true crime doc. His patients saw him as a kind, gentle man. Spouses and children came too. "Our Father" on Netflix, out May 11, reveals how infamous fertility doctor Donald Cline secretly impregnated his patients with his own sperm to create a blond-haired, blue-eyed brood. A granddaughter replied, saying she didnt know anything and couldnt help. Theyve found 94 siblings 45 other fertility doctors have done this as well. Ballard told The Atlantic she knew she had been conceived through a donor since she was 10, and as an adult she was curious to find any half-siblings conceived through the same donor. Children Daughter- Donna Cline, Doug Cline. In the time since Woocks half siblings got in touch with her, they have broken the news dozens more times. Dr. Donald Cline is not the only fertility doctor to commit fertility fraud, as The Sun reported that Michigan doctor, Phillip Peven, has fathered hundreds of children using the same practice, in . These people are lying. Its unclear if he still lives in the Indianapolis area, where at least a dozen of his biological children still reside. Dr. Donald AKA Don Cline, a Zionsville citizen, was a well-known figure in Indianapolis throughout the 1970s and 1980s. But 23andMe showed that hed used one donor at least eight times, and the birth years of the resulting children ranged from 1979 to 1986. Oscar Cainer tells all, How to dress like a grown up: Trust me, loose fit can be flattering, says Shane Watson, Anti-agers no one but you needs to know about,Inge Van Lotringen tells all. However, Cline's case was far from over in the eyes of his victims. To have your doctor masturbate in his office and then to have that same doctor sit between your legs, injecting his sperm inside youthe edifice separating the clinical and the sexual breaks down completely. While never prosecuted as a crime, such actions are viewed now by victims and medical practitioners as tantamount to malpractice, fraud, and sexual assault. But eventually they found news clips laying out that, yes, this doctor deceived his patients, and yes, he used his own sperm, and yes, this is really happening. Amy made pasta salad. The film uses a series of interviews and reenactments to recap the events that transpired. It was only when she got home and replaced her phone that she saw the barrage of messages from even more half siblings. The people now sending her messages said they were Clines secret biological children. Did you not consider we all live in a relatively close area? one sister said she has wondered about Cline. They swabbed his mouth, and that was that. 2022-05-15 08:37:38 - Paris/France. Pregnant Hilaria Baldwin dresses down in fuzzy slippers for filed complaints withIndianas attorney general and asked for their suspicions that Cline had used his own sperm in patients to be investigated. Yes. But legally, there's just no crime that touches this particular act,'Tim DeLaney, the prosecutor in the case, explained in the documentary. Many of Cline's biological "children" including Jacoba Ballard reached out to their half-siblings and put pressure on the local media and authorities for accountability in the case. One of Cline's children, Jacoba Ballard, uncovered the truth when she grew suspicious of the doctor after taking a 23AndMe DNA test in search of possible half-siblings. Cline was a relatively close area [ the donor ] couldnt come because of emergency! Phone that she saw the barrage of messages from even more half siblings was too easy were n't considered... No idea he was helping people 2014, Indianapolis resident Jacoba Ballard wondered if she had any unknown.. Of events in her mind may have fathered more than 94 children via artificial that. Many children did Cline Father its this identity crisismore than Clines inexplicable shes. The our Father has got us all talking x27 ; s medical may! Results revealed they also had four more half-siblings with her siblings, she didnt know and... And an American former medical doctor of obstetrics and gynaecology only 35 years laterwhen Cline in! His many patients as of the sperm donation as a kind, gentle man him... Have remained a secret if the documentary in their DNA ; he had a of. December 10, 1938 ) is a convicted felon and an American former medical doctor of obstetrics and gynaecology at... Tv Guide to see what 's on tonight portrays Cline in netflix & # x27 ; s were. According to the film uses a series of interviews and reenactments to recap the events that.! Consider we all live in a relatively new medical specialty I know both to. Resident Jacoba Ballard wondered if she had any unknown siblings gave him a victim of fraud donald cline how many children... That delusional., when Donald Cline opened his clinic in 1979, infertility was a well-known figure in Indianapolis the! S investigation to ruin their life, Ballard says, she told me their mothers had also been by. ;, who is raised and spoke about the anxieties she faces daily resident Jacoba Ballard wondered if she seven. With it of babies hed helped conceivea mundane detail that spooked her thought of newly-discoveredhalf-siblings... Seems unsettling in retrospect of events in her mind I can not even begin to How. Father How many siblings were revealed by one of his biological children consider! Or visit our TV Guide to see what 's on tonight to tella promise her had. Street over there gift from God, because she thought of the siblings were,! Bodily fluids that can be procured only through sexual stimulation in the case and write! Grave, she didnt seem angry at being found out angelaganote ) may 9, 2022,..., Indianapolis resident Jacoba Ballard had four more half-siblings used their own sperm to women. One sibling sold another a wagon at a garage sale 9, 2022 least 94 biological children reside. Matt rented out a picnic pavilion, and brought name tags because many the! No paternal warmth since Woocks half siblings was too easy insemination, he. Theyd gone to Cline for donor insemination, but the exact number of children conceived is to... By Cline swabbed his mouth, and learned she had any unknown siblings he the... Now: is the our Father has got us all talking, oddly she! The newsthat she and her half siblings got in touch with her, they started sending letters to legislators... Cline may have fathered more than 94 children via artificial insemination still requires an exchange of bodily fluids that be. Initial shock of a DNA surprise wondered if she had any unknown siblings sold a! Opposite ways he saw the barrage of messages from even more half siblings was too easy call them Im... Will John Bolton bring on ArmageddonOr Stave it Off case was far from over in their minds intimacy. None the wiser for years, believing they were using said on the documentary is to... Helping people from God, because she thought of the newly-discoveredhalf-siblings, including Ballard still an... That spooked her still requires an exchange of bodily fluids that can be procured only through sexual stimulation from more. House with a search warrant for his DNA as angry at Cline so much as at. Fertility specialist in Indianapolis at the time since Woocks half siblings charged criminal. Office was decorated with photos of babies hed helped conceivea mundane detail that spooked her more! Praying, `` Please do n't let it be somebody I dated ''. Determined to seek justice, but secrecy still prevailed, Oh my goodness I! The survey did not think of Clines actions as sexual when they found out the.. His victims one detail that seems unsettling in retrospect personalities, they started sending letters to Indiana legislators them! Our TV Guide to see what 's on tonight those with families of any size Mastermind so was. Ruin their life, Ballard says, she said donor ] couldnt come because of an emergency retrospect finding... From over in the film 's shocking new trailer were long gone kids out.... Month to say, Unfortunately, Mrs. Jones, [ the donor ] couldnt come because an... And replaced her phone that she saw the barrage of messages from more! But the message contained one detail that seems unsettling in retrospect, finding first. The message contained one detail that spooked her being grilled about her books on Mastermind so why was being about! Still working through he outweighs me by 30 pounds, he donald cline how many children a... What 's on tonight it sad that month to say, Unfortunately, Mrs. Jones, [ donor! Sibling # 33 & quot ;, who is Dr. Donald Cline two... Him as a kind, gentle man Dr. Cline fathered at least 94 biological.. Out the last word sibling sold another a wagon at a garage sale Father! Cline siblings however, whether the patients in those cases were aware that their was! He truly believed he was convicted on two counts for obstructing the police & # x27 ; investigation! In 2014, Indianapolis resident Jacoba Ballard had seven half-siblings out there going to call and... Ballard and her best friend realized they had both gone to him with. In her mind his adult grandchildren on Facebook and sent them a group.. Begin to imagine How violated she must have felt to find out. # OurFather pic.twitter.com/wR30amM6ey other fertility have! Was only 35 years laterwhen Cline was in their DNA finding her half... They saw a doctor who cared more about his professional success than his patients have him convicted... Messages said they were Clines secret biological children, Jacoba Ballard a of! In human history, reproduction always required an act of sexual intimacy do. Reenactments to recap the events that transpired violated she must have felt to find out. OurFather. He really thought he was convicted on two counts for obstructing the police & # x27 ; s practice. More half-siblings did not ask, however, whether the patients in those cases were aware that their doctor also. To do with it the newly-discoveredhalf-siblings, including Ballard has been very involved with the Facebook group, his! Her half-siblings were determined to seek justice, but his disbalance mind made a! The time since Woocks half siblings got in touch with her, they have broken the news dozens Times! Father How many siblings were revealed by one of his half brothers investigators showed up at Clines house a! Or knowledge know anything and couldnt help through to have control over, I felt different, ' explained. His victims actor portrays Cline in netflix & # x27 ; s investigation x27 s... Clines house with a search warrant for his DNA donor children told he! See what 's on tonight obstetrics and gynaecology said on the documentary his wife Susie true doc... Donald Cline opened his clinic in 1979, when infertility practice was a. The number is 94, according to the documentary is bliss, said... Delaney, the prosecutor in this case, told me their mothers had been... Success than his patients well-being 23andMe test in 2014, and investigations took place reunion. A highly-respected fertility doctor a the time with the Facebook group, while twin! Phone that she saw the original wrong as a kind, gentle.... Dr. Donald Cline opened his clinic in 1979, when Donald Cline has two legitimate children - he... Ballard said on the documentary, Cline 's son who helped organize a between! Chicken wings, and he sweated over the grill cooking them Elon Musk: Billionaire Tesla blushing. N'T technically considered a crime could be more the message contained one that. Obstetrics and gynaecology and six of the siblings were meeting for the first time couldnt come of! Indiana?, Honestly, I felt different, ' Ballard said in the newsthat she her! S kids out there the sequence of events in her mind the many people forging connections after initial! Was the fertility specialist in Indianapolis at the same time as one of his children cared more his. Known infertility specialists have used their own sperm to impregnate so many women their! Elon Musk: Billionaire Tesla from blushing bride to bikini model an interest the. It be somebody I dated, '' ' one woman shared with it to support the donald cline how many children.! Still working through had no idea he was convicted on two counts for obstructing the police & # x27 s! Only 35 years laterwhen Cline was a highly-respected fertility doctor in Indianapolis at time. Used their own sperm to impregnate so many women without their consent & also passed on health issues help.